1990

• First Team: Errick Jones
• Second Team: Tracy Bacon, Mark Broncatello, Mike Brown

1991

• First Team: Tracey Bacon, Tim McWilliams
• Second Team: Eric Rappa, Brad Baglio

1992

• First Team: Brad Baglio
• Second Team: Eric Rappa, Lance Nemitz

1993

• First Team: Eric Rappa, Jeff Klusek, Jeff Onze, Dan Moore, Lance Nemitz, Jeff Bates
• Second Team: Mike Clawson
• Coach of the Year: Bill Bowe

1994

• First Team: Matt Brauer, Jeff Onze, Dan Moore, Greg Constantino, Jeff Bates

1995

• First Team: Ben Tepedino, Jeff Onze, Greg Constantino, Jeff Bates
• Second Team: Andy McDougal, Dan Clawson, Mike Clawson

1996

• First Team: Ryan Wade
• Second Team: Shawn Whalen, Fran Sargent

1997

• First Team: Matt DeVinney
• Second Team: Matt Miller, Mike Cooney, Bryan Sanchez, Chuck Abate

1998

• First Team: Matt DeVinney, Adam Schorr, Bryan Sanchez, Brian Keenan, Bob Trumbull
• Second Team: Ryan Wade, Tom Kenney, Ryan Schaefer
• Coach of the Year: Bill Bowe

1999

• First Team: Adam Schorr, Jim Coyne, Chad Manning, Tom Kenney, Justin Constantino, David Booth, Bryan Sanchez
• Second Team: Chris Henninger, Bob Trumbull
• Coach of the Year: Bill Bowe

2000

• First Team: Jim Coyne, Chris Henninger, Adam Schorr, Jason Culonio, Justin Constantino
• Second Team: Brent Alvut

2001

• First Team: Sean McWilliams, Mark Constantino, Matt Walters, Brandon Borgna
• Second Team: Steve LeGrett, Kurt Jung, Brent Alvut, Andrew Potter

2002

• First Team: Sean McWilliams, Kurt Jung, Mark Constantino, Tony Cirincione, Steve LeGrett
• Second Team: Joe Caggianelli

2003

• First Team: Brad Maltman, Matt Chapman, Tony Cirincione
• Second Team: Nate DiGrande, Kyle Holmes

2004

• Second Team: Patrick McCarthy, Matt Densmore, Kyle Holmes, Geoff Smith, Matt Chapman

2005

• First Team: Patrick McCarthy, Casey Rice, Geoff Smith

2006

• First Team: David Herman, Mike Pease, Geoff Smith, Craig Tauterouff
• Second Team: Jordan Buck, Tom VanDamme

2007

• First Team: Robert Bradshaw, Dan Booth, Jordan Buck
• Second Team: Mike Pease

2008

• First Team: Dan Booth, Nick Carlson, Justin D’Amato, Ken Ingersoll
• Second Team: John Sculli, Tyler Thompson, Matt McCarthy, Kevin Donk

2009

• First Team: Justin D’Amato, Cass Roberts, Parker Ross, Jonathan Mastin, Robert Wied, Tyler Thompson, James Hoffend, Matt McCarthy
• Second Team: Nick Carlson, Thomas Fountain, Will Sigel
• Player of the Year: Cass Roberts
• Coach of the Year: Dale Werth

2010

• First Team: Justin D’Amato, Parker Ross
• Second Team: Kyle Ficarella, Cass Roberts, David Taft

2011

• Second Team: Adam Scott

2012

• Second Team: Patrick Carbary

2013

• First Team: Patrick Coyne, Sean Outhouse
• Second Team: Colton Ceravolo, Shawn Foster

2014

• Player of the Year: Adam Scott
• First Team: Patrick Coyne, Chris Lovin
• Second Team: Colton Ceravolo, Tim Ryan, Travis Welch
• Coach of the Year: Dale Werth

2015

• First Team: Chris Lovin, Tanner Cooper
• Second Team: Patrick Coyne, Tim Ryan

2016

• First Team: Cody Cooper, Tanner Cooper
• Second Team: Bennett Hanford, Jake Riddle, Mike Zimmerman

2017

• Player of the Year: Tanner Cooper
• First Team: Brian Hoffman, Matthew Carbary, Seth Vigneri
• Second Team: Connor Fisher
• Coach of the Year: Dale Werth

2018

• First Team: Michael Sculli, Cooper Crunick, Seth Vigneri
• Second Team: Jordie Johnstone, Connor Fisher

2019

• Player of the Year: Michael Sculli
• First Team: Cooper Crunick, Dylan MacKenzie, Seth Vigneri
• Second Team: Joe Brinza
• Coach of the Year: Dale Werth